Derry Daily
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Features
  • Courts
  • Business
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Jobs
Sunday 24°CMonday 16°C

Derry Daily Derry Daily Derry Daily

  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Features
  • Courts
  • Business
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Jobs
CourtsDerry CityNewsPolitics

Decisions not to charge Bloody Sunday soldiers with murder ‘unimpeachable’

September 22, 2021
ShareTweet

DECISIONS not to pursue murder charges against soldiers for the Bloody Sunday killings are legally “unimpeachable”, the High Court heard today.

Counsel for the Public Prosecution Service (PPS) insisted the authority had properly considered the evidential test and likely outcome of any criminal process over the shootings in Derry in January 1972.

Tony McGleenan QC also claimed the authority would be abdicating its responsibilities by bringing to trial cases regarded as having no realistic prospect of securing convictions.

Thirteen people were shot dead when members of the Parachute Regiment opened fire on civil rights demonstrators in the city.

A 14th person later died of their injuries.

In 2010 the Saville Inquiry into the events on Bloody Sunday established the innocence of all of those who died.

Relatives of seven of the victims are seeking a judicial review of decisions which mean five of the ex-paratroopers will not face trial.

In July the PPS announced it was dropping charges against British Paratrooper Soldier F for the murders of William McKinney (26) and James Wray (22) plus five counts of attempted murder.

The case against him was reviewed after criminal proceedings against two other military veterans for Troubles-era offences collapsed in Belfast earlier this year.

Based on an assessment of the admissibility of evidence from the time, it was concluded that the test for prosecution was no longer met.

The PPS is also being challenged for not charging former paratroopers with the murders of Jackie Duddy (17), Michael Kelly (17), John Young (17), Michael McDaid (20), and 41-year-old father-of-six Bernard McGuigan.

The case involves a dispute about whether statements taken from soldiers in 1972 would be ruled inadmissible in any criminal trial.

Lawyers for the families contend the prosecuting authority’s assessment of the evidence is legally and fundamentally flawed.

But highlighting the code for prosecutors, Mr McGleenan rejected claims that cases should be brought to trial even when they decided the evidential test was not met.

“That is a contentious submission which involves an abdication of the responsibilities of the Public Prosecution Service, not their discharge,” he said.

He told the court the case involved “borderline judgments and acute difficulty”.

James Wray (left) and William McKinney murdered by British soldier on Bloody Sunday in Derry in January 1972

Senior counsel in Northern Ireland, England and Wales, and a former First Treasury Counsel all advised on the merits of prosecution, the court heard.

According to Mr McGleenan likely defence arguments at a criminal trial were also predicted.

“It is about anticipating how this will fare in the Crown Court, when faced with specialist criminal counsel who will, in the vernacular, know all the moves,” he said.

During submissions he stressed the challenge featured no allegations of bad faith or any breach of the code for prosecutors.

Any potential error of law would be limited to a “tangential point” which would make no significant difference, it was claimed.

Mr McGleenan stressed: “We are analysing the reasonableness of the forecast made by the prosecutor.

“If it is within a reasonable range of forecasts of what the Crown Court will do, in terms of a conviction, then it is unimpeachable, even if there is some peripheral error.”

The hearing continues.

Decisions not to charge Bloody Sunday soldiers with murder ‘unimpeachable’ was last modified: September 22nd, 2021 by cassoscoop

Tags:
Bernard McGuiganBloody SundayBritish paratrooperscode for prosecutorsDecisions not to charge Bloody Sunday soldiers with murder ‘unimpeachable’ghigh courtJames WrayJOHN YOUNGMICHAEL KELLYMICHAEL MCDAIDPUBLIC PROSECUTION SERVICESoldier FTony McGleena QCWilliam McKinney
ShareTweet

LEAVE A COMMENT

You may also like

Charles Dooher murder bid: Man arrested in...

24 hours ago

The LYCRA Company staff excited to continue...

1 day ago

Man arrested in Derry over murder bid...

2 days ago

Man to face Derry court over cannabis...

2 days ago

Man arrested in Derry after 120 cannabis...

3 days ago

Derry Labour Market Partnership celebrate success of...

3 days ago

Savour the best of the North West...

3 days ago

Bin collections and Recycling Centres operate as...

3 days ago

Finance Minister visits sites of Derry Strabane...

3 days ago

Durkan: We need to get serious about...

3 days ago

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Email

Features

  • Sun, sea, spectacular views, historical charm and fabulous food. Tunisia of course

    April 5, 2024
  • Magical trip to see Santa from Belfast

    December 20, 2023
  • DD Travel Feature: Cork’s amazing The Montenotte Hotel

    April 18, 2023
  • Derry cancer survivor Noeleen McMorris reveals importance of awareness

    July 25, 2022
  • Competition! Win tickets to Northern Ireland v England Women’s Euro 2022 match

    June 17, 2022

Courts

  • Man to face Derry court over cannabis plants seizure

    July 11, 2025
  • Man charged to court over Derry drugs seizure

    July 6, 2025
  • Drink-driver charged to court over Derry collision

    July 5, 2025
  • Derry priest faces seven more child sex charges

    July 4, 2025
  • Man charged with possessing indecent images of children

    July 4, 2025

Donegal Daily

    Read More

    • News
    • Sport
    • Courts
    • Jobs
    • Features
    • Business
    • Politics

    Information

    • Contact Us
    • About
    • Advertise WIth Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • Terms & Conditions
    Derry Daily

    © 2025 Derry Daily. All rights reserved.


    Back To Top

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy