FINN Harps ended Derry City’s dreams of silverware and reaching the quarter finals of the FAI Cup with a controversial penalty decision tonight in the North West derby.
A Tunde Owolabi penalty 16 minutes from time for Harps proved to be the only goal in the Extra.ie FAI Cup second round tie against The Candystripes.
The Belgian scored a hat-trick last week against St Patrick’s Athletic and stepped up to score with conviction from 12 yards.
The disputed penalty followed an alleged foul by Ronan Boyce on Ryan Rainey, to give the Ballybofey side their first ever win over their rivals in the FAI Cup.
Keenly contested with few chances, the home side managed by the suspended Ollie Horgan who watched from the terraces in the 800-strong crowd, were the ones who pushed more for the winner, while Ruaidhrí Higgins’ team only really got into the game when they went a goal down.
Gerard Doherty, the goalkeeper who made 324 appearances for Derry City, was making his Harps debut against his hometown club.
He made three crucial late saves to send his new employers through to the quarter-finals, sinking the hearts of Derry City fans.
Neither goalkeeper was seriously tested in the first half, with Harps left-back Jordan Mustoe fizzing a couple of shots over at the River End and Doherty had no bother gathering a scuffed effort from Danny Lafferty.
Right on the stroke of half-time, Owolabi swiveled in a crowded penalty area and saw his shot blocked by Ciaran Coll with Rainey following up to also see his shot blocked by Jack Malone amid pretty boisterous penalty shouts for handball.
Both meetings in the league this term ended in 2-1 victories for the visitors, with Adam Foley scoring a late winner at the Brandywell in May before a double from Will Patching sealing victory for Derry in Ballybofey in June.
Ten minutes into the second half, Foley’s snapshot from the edge of the penalty area went just over Nathan Gartside’s crossbar. Then, Foley, from an erratic crossfield clearance from Eoin Toal, outmuscled Lafferty and cut inside to shoot, drawing a full stretch save from Gartside in the Candystripes’ goal on the hour.
Following the goal, Owolabi headed another chance wide and Doherty in goal knew he’d probably not see the night out as quiet as it had been. Nine minutes from time he got down well to save from substitute Evan McLaughlin, with the visitors’ first meaningful attempt of the night.
Jamie McGonigle, three minutes into injury time, cut inside Karl O’Sullivan and drew another save from Doherty, who then had to be at full stretch to tip over a speculative strike from former Harps captain Coll.
Derry showed a type of urgency in the closing stages that was not evident throughout.
Craig Forrester, from a St Pat’s penalty, is the only man to breach the Harps defence in the last five outings – that’s 537 minutes with Fairview Rangers having taken Horgan’s team to extra-time in the previous round.
The draw for the quarter-finals will take place on Tuesday evening.
Sadly, after a good run of recent form, Derry City won’t be in that draw.
Next up for City is an away clash next Friday, September 3 against Bohemians in the league with kick off at Dalymount Park at 7.45 pm.
Finn Harps: Gerard Doherty; Ethan Boyle (Kosovar Sadiki 67), Shane McEleney, Dave Webster, Jordan Mustoe (Karl O’Sullivan 45+1); Adam Foley, Mark Coyle, Johnny Dunleavy, Ryan Rainey; Barry McNamee; Babatunde Owolabi (Sean Boyd 84).
Derry City: Nathan Gartside; Ronan Boyce (Patrick Ferry 84), Eoin Toal, Ciaran Coll; Ciaron Harkin (Evan McLaughlin 77); Jack Malone, Bastien Hery (James Akintunde 65), Joe Thompson, Danny Lafferty; Junior Ogedi Uzokwe, Jamie McGonigle.
Referee: Rob Harvey.Tags: