Derry Daily
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Features
  • Courts
  • Business
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Jobs
Monday 6°CTuesday 5°C

Derry Daily Derry Daily Derry Daily

  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Features
  • Courts
  • Business
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Jobs
CourtsDerry CityHealthNews

Daniel Hegarty murder: Soldier B loses legal battle

December 17, 2020
ShareTweet

Daneil Hegarty was shot dead by a British soldier in Derry in 1972

A former soldier has lost a legal challenge against being prosecuted for the murder of a teenage boy in Derry 48 years ago.

The ex-serviceman claimed the decision to charge him over the killing of Daniel Hegarty put him at heightened risk of sudden death due to ill health.

But his challenge was rejected by Court of Appeal judges on Thursday.

Lord Justice Treacy said to accept it could give potential immunity for any suspect with a medical complaint.

“If correct, a serial killer or rapist could not lawfully be prosecuted if the medical evidence established that a decision to prosecute would expose him to that risk,” he said.

Fifteen-year-old Daniel was shot twice in the head during an Army operation in Creggan in July 1972.

In April 2019, the Public Prosecution Service (PPS) announced that the military veteran, referred to as Soldier B, was to be charged with his murder.

He is further accused of intentionally wounding Daniel’s cousin Christopher Hegarty, then aged 17, in the same incident.

The shootings happened during Operation Motorman, when British troops were deployed in Derry at the height of the Troubles to clear so-called no-go areas.

In 2011, an inquest jury unanimously found Daniel posed no risk and had been shot without warning.

A decision was taken not to prosecute Soldier B in 2016.

But, in May 2018, the High Court quashed that determination following legal action by the Hegarty family.

The director of public prosecutions for the North of Ireland, Stephen Herron, then carried out a review of the case before announcing charges would be brought.

Lawyers representing the former soldier sought a judicial review of those decisions, claiming they violated Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Reporting restrictions imposed earlier in the case were lifted to enable publication of full details of the challenge.

It was claimed that prosecutors failed to take Soldier B’s health into account.

British Army’s Operation Motorman in July 1972 in Derry

However, Lord Justice Treacy, sitting with Mr Justice O’Hara and Sir John Gillen, found that the director had carefully considered his condition.

Medical reports indicated the consequences of the decision to prosecute Soldier B would be more frequent chest pain and an “unquantifiable” increased risk of sudden death.

A doctor noted that no-one could predict when the deterioration in heart failure may occur, the court heard.

Describing the challenge as “bold”, Lord Justice Treacy said, if successful, prosecutors could be inundated with medical reports from suspects trying to persuade them that they should not face trial.

Proceedings might also be hit by delays, endangering confidence in the criminal justice system, he said.

“If the argument of the applicant were accepted it would confer de facto immunity on any suspect with a medical condition capable of similarly increasing risk, consequential upon higher levels of stress resulting from a decision to prosecute.

“Furthermore, if the applicant’s contention was right, the increase in the risk of death arising from the prosecution could as a matter of principle be deployed more than once.”

Dismissing the challenge, the senior judge concluded: “The system of safeguards and protections is sufficient to satisfy the obligations of the state under Article 2.”

Related Topics

Daniel Hegarty murder: Soldier B loses legal battle was last modified: December 20th, 2020 by cassoscoop
cassoscoop

Tags:
COURT OF APPEALCRegganDaniel Hegarty murder: Soldier B loses legal battleDerryDirector of Public Prosecutionsdoctor's medical reportJuly 1972Lord Justice TreacyMr Justrice O'HaraSir John GillenStephen Harron
ShareTweet

LEAVE A COMMENT

You may also like

Anderson calls for review of taxi scheme...

41 mins ago

NWRC receives Elemental Prescription to improve student...

2 hours ago

Minister: New domestic abuse law gives victims...

2 hours ago

Coronavirus: ‘Toughest week yet’ of pandemic for...

3 hours ago

Police warn Derry public over suspicious objects

5 hours ago

Derry hospitality facing St Patrick’s Day in...

1 day ago

Rian’s sky dive for Foyle Search and...

1 day ago

Duffy: LED street lighting scheme for Moss...

1 day ago

Durkan welcomes certainty over Covid business insurance...

1 day ago

22 more deaths, 705 further cases in...

2 days ago

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Email

Features

  • DD Travel: Living like a local in Lixouri

    December 17, 2020
  • DD Travel: Kefalonia and her southern shores

    November 29, 2020
  • DD Travel: Kefalonia an Ionian discovery

    November 17, 2020
  • Lurgybrack Open Farm: The perfect place for family fun this Bank Holiday weekend

    July 10, 2019
  • DD Travel feature: Vibrant Verona

    May 2, 2019

Courts

  • Man charged over police station hoax bomb call

    January 13, 2021
  • New Year’s Eve party: Derry duo in court

    January 2, 2021
  • Derry man for trial over alleged wedding rape

    December 27, 2020
  • Derry ‘hate crime’ assault left victim unconscious

    December 23, 2020
  • Daniel Hegarty murder: Soldier B loses legal battle

    December 17, 2020

Donegal Daily

  • Seven Donegal walking routes on track for upgrades

    3 hours ago
  • Covid-19 hospital admissions rise again in Letterkenny

    4 hours ago
  • Covid: Another 13 deaths and 2,944 cases with 112 in Donegal

    19 hours ago

Read More

  • News
  • Sport
  • Courts
  • Jobs
  • Features
  • Business
  • Politics

Information

  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise WIth Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions
Derry Daily

© 2021 Derry Daily. All rights reserved.


Back To Top